Top 10 Shopify Payments Problems (and How to Avoid Them)

It's powerful, flexible, and packed with features. 

But when it comes to payments, many small and medium-sized business owners discover that Shopify Payments problems can bring an otherwise thriving store to a halt.

Whether it's an unexpected account hold, confusing transaction fees, a disabled payout, or a checkout that simply doesn't work for your international customers — Shopify Payments problems are more common than the platform's marketing would suggest. 

And for SMBs with tight margins and no dedicated finance team, these disruptions can be genuinely costly.

In this blog, we break down the top 10 Shopify payment gateway issues for SMBs, explain exactly why each one happens, and share how you can avoid — or work around — every single one. 

And if you're finding that the problems keep stacking up, we'll also introduce a simpler alternative worth considering.

The Top 10 Shopify Payments Problems (and How to Avoid Each One)

#1  Account Suspended Without Warning

One of the most common — and disruptive — Shopify Payments problems is waking up to a suspended account with no prior notice. 

Shopify's automated compliance system continuously scans your account for risk signals: product categories, chargeback rates, transaction volume spikes, and KYC document mismatches. 

Any of these can trigger an automatic suspension, often before a human even reviews the case. Revenue stops immediately, and the appeals process can take days or weeks.

How to avoid it: Review Shopify's Acceptable Use Policy regularly. Keep your business documentation up to date. Avoid making sudden changes to your product catalog or pricing structure, especially during high-volume periods. Always have a backup payment gateway connected so that sales can continue if Shopify Payments is taken offline.

#2  Funds Held in Reserve

Shopify may withhold a percentage of your payouts — sometimes up to 20% — and hold them in reserve for 30, 90, or even 120 days. 

This typically happens when your chargeback rate crosses 1%, your business is flagged as high-risk, or your account experiences a sudden spike in sales volume. 

For SMBs relying on consistent cash flow, a payment reserve can cause serious operational disruption.

How to avoid it: Keep your chargeback rate well below 1% by maintaining accurate product descriptions, clear refund policies, and proactive customer communication. Monitor your Shopify Payments dashboard regularly for early warning flags. If a reserve is applied, contact Shopify support immediately and provide any documentation they request.

#3  High and Confusing Transaction Fees

Shopify Payments is promoted as 'free' with your subscription — but the fees add up quickly and aren't always transparent.

On the Basic plan, you'll pay 2.9% + 30¢ per online transaction. Use a third-party gateway? Add another 2% on top. Sell internationally? Expect currency conversion fees of 1.5%–2%. 

For SMBs doing volume, these layered costs become a significant margin drain that was never part of their original cost calculation.

How to avoid it: Map out your true cost per transaction before committing to a plan. If international sales are a major part of your business, model out what currency conversion fees will cost you at scale. Consider whether a platform with no additional third-party gateway surcharge — like Prosperna — would be more cost-effective for your business model.

#4  Shopify Payments Not Available in Your Country

Shopify Payments is only available to merchants registered in approximately 25 countries — primarily in North America, Western Europe, and a handful of Asia-Pacific markets. 

If your business is based in the Philippines, India, Nigeria, or most of Southeast Asia, Latin America, or Africa, Shopify Payments simply isn't an option. You're forced into third-party gateways, which trigger Shopify's extra transaction fee on every sale. This is one of the most widespread Shopify payment gateway issues for SMBs operating outside of supported regions.

How to avoid it: Research your payment gateway options before building on Shopify. If Shopify Payments isn't available in your country, calculate the cumulative cost of third-party gateway fees over 12 months. Alternatively, consider platforms like Prosperna that offer direct Stripe integration with no additional platform surcharge — giving you the same payment infrastructure without the geographic gatekeeping.

#5  Payout Delays and Reconciliation Gaps

Your sales dashboard shows $5,000 — but only $4,750 lands in your bank account, and three days later than expected. 

Payout delays and reconciliation gaps are a persistent frustration for Shopify merchants. 

Fees, refunds, and chargebacks are all deducted before funds are transferred, creating a gap between reported revenue and actual deposits. International merchants face additional lags due to currency conversion and regional payout schedules.

How to avoid it: Set up a simple cash flow spreadsheet that accounts for payout timing and fee deductions — don't rely on your Shopify revenue dashboard as your real-time financial picture. Use Shopify's Payouts section under Settings > Payments to track deductions. For international merchants, allow an additional 2–5 business days buffer in your cash flow planning.

#6  Excessive Chargebacks Threatening Account Health

Chargebacks are one of the biggest ongoing Shopify Payments problems for growing stores. 

When a customer disputes a charge with their bank, the funds are reversed from your account — and you're also charged a dispute fee (around $15 in the US). 

If your chargeback rate exceeds 0.65%, you risk being placed on Visa or Mastercard monitoring programs. Exceed 1%, and Shopify may suspend or terminate your Payments account entirely. 

Friendly fraud — where customers falsely claim they didn't authorize a charge — accounts for an estimated 72–75% of chargebacks.

How to avoid it: Write clear, detailed product descriptions that set accurate expectations. Include explicit refund and return policies at checkout. Send proactive shipping notifications and delivery confirmations. Flag and avoid fulfilling high-risk orders. Use Shopify's built-in fraud analysis tools and consider a chargeback prevention app to monitor dispute patterns before they escalate.

#7  Shop Pay Not Converting for Your Audience

Shopify promotes Shop Pay as converting up to 50% better than standard guest checkout. 

But that conversion lift is primarily observed in US-centric markets where customers already have Shop Pay accounts and trust the brand. 

For SMBs serving Southeast Asian, African, or Latin American customers — where Shop Pay adoption is low and local payment preferences differ significantly — the accelerated checkout simply doesn't deliver the same results.

How to avoid it: Test your checkout flow with a sample of your actual target audience. If Shop Pay's conversion advantage isn't materializing for your market, explore local payment method integrations that match your customers' preferences. Platforms like Prosperna, with Stripe's support for local payment methods and digital wallets, may offer a checkout experience that resonates better with global customers.

#8  KYC Verification Delays and Document Mismatches

Shopify Payments requires KYC (Know Your Customer) verification of your business identity. 

If your submitted documents don't exactly match your account details — even a slight address format difference or a name abbreviation — verification can stall or fail entirely, leaving your payouts frozen while the review process plays out. 

New merchants frequently encounter this as one of their first Shopify payment gateway issues for SMBs.

How to avoid it: Before submitting KYC documents, cross-check every detail against your legal business registration: business name spelling, address format, and tax identification numbers. Submit documents in the highest resolution possible. If verification stalls, contact Shopify support proactively — don't wait for an automated resolution.

#9  Limited or Unavailable Payment Methods for International Customers

Shopify Payments supports major credit and debit cards — Visa, Mastercard, Amex — plus Apple Pay and Google Pay. 

But international customers often prefer local payment methods: bank transfers, mobile wallets, buy-now-pay-later options, or regional card networks like JCB. 

If your store can't support these, you're losing sales at the checkout stage to payment method friction — a silent revenue leak that's easy to overlook.

How to avoid it: Audit your customer locations and payment preferences using Shopify Analytics. If a significant portion of your revenue comes from regions where local payment methods dominate, research gateway solutions that natively support those methods. Stripe — which Prosperna integrates directly — supports bank redirects and local payment methods across many supported regions.

#10  No Clear Path Forward When Problems Arise

This may be the most frustrating Shopify Payments problem of all: when something goes wrong, the resolution process is opaque and slow. 

Automated system flags don't come with detailed explanations. Support wait times can be long. 

And for an SMB without a dedicated finance or operations team, navigating the appeals process while simultaneously trying to run a business is genuinely overwhelming.

How to avoid it: Document everything. Keep records of your business registration, transaction history, customer communications, and shipping confirmations. If your account is flagged, respond to Shopify's requests immediately and in full. And seriously evaluate whether a platform with simpler, more transparent payment operations would serve your business better in the long run.

Tired of Running Into These Problems? There's a Simpler Way.

If you've experienced more than a couple of the Shopify Payments problems on this list, you already know how much time and energy they consume — time that should be going into growing your business.

Prosperna is an all-in-one eCommerce platform built specifically for SMBs, with Stripe integrated directly as your payment gateway. It's designed to eliminate the complexity and friction that make Shopify payment gateway issues for SMBs such a persistent headache.

Here's what Prosperna's Stripe integration gives you instead:

• No geographic gatekeeping — Stripe supports merchants across 45+ countries, including many markets Shopify Payments excludes
• No additional platform transaction fee when using Stripe — you pay only Stripe's standard processing rates
• 135+ currencies supported — your customers pay in their local currency, no Shopify Markets setup required
• Apple Pay, Google Pay, Link, and local payment methods depending on your region
• PCI-compliant, fraud-protected, with 3D Secure authentication built in
• Setup in 1–2 minutes — beginner-level, no developer needed
• Single, unified dashboard for your store and payments — no reconciliation gap between two platforms

The bottom line: Prosperna was built so that SMBs don't have to spend their energy managing payment platform problems. With Stripe connected directly and no Shopify-style compliance layer sitting on top, you get stable, global payment processing that works — from day one.

Ready to Leave the Payment Headaches Behind?

Whether you're actively dealing with Shopify Payments problems right now or simply want to build your store on a more stable foundation, Prosperna gives you a payment experience designed for the way SMBs actually operate — lean, global, and focused on selling.

Try Prosperna free — and spend less time on payment problems, more time on growth.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the most common Shopify Payments problem for SMBs?

Account suspension and fund holds are the most reported issues, typically triggered by chargeback rates exceeding 1%, sudden sales volume spikes, or KYC document mismatches. These are especially disruptive for small businesses because they stop revenue immediately and can take days to resolve.

2. Can I use Shopify without Shopify Payments?

Yes — you can use Shopify with a third-party payment gateway like Stripe, PayPal, or a local provider. However, Shopify charges an additional transaction fee (0.5%–2% depending on your plan) on every sale processed through a third-party gateway, which adds up quickly for growing businesses.

3. How do I keep my chargeback rate below Shopify's threshold?

The key is prevention: write accurate product descriptions, maintain clear refund and shipping policies, send proactive fulfillment updates, and flag high-risk orders before fulfilling them. Keeping your chargeback rate below 0.65% keeps you out of Visa and Mastercard monitoring programs; below 1% keeps your Shopify Payments account in good standing.

4. How is Prosperna different from Shopify when it comes to payments?

Prosperna integrates directly with Stripe without an additional platform transaction fee for using it. There's no proprietary payment compliance layer, no geographic restriction on which countries can access the payment gateway, and the entire setup takes 1–2 minutes. For SMBs, this means fewer surprise fees, fewer disruptions, and a simpler overall payment experience.

5. Does Prosperna support international payments?

Yes. Through Stripe, Prosperna supports 135+ currencies and payment methods including credit cards, debit cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Link. Depending on your region and Stripe account setup, local payment methods like bank redirects may also be available.

Final Thoughts

Shopify Payments problems aren't random — they're structural. 

The platform was built at scale for a global market, and its compliance systems, geographic restrictions, and fee structures reflect that. 

For enterprise merchants with large teams and high volumes, these systems are manageable. For SMBs, they're often a persistent source of stress and lost revenue.

Understanding the top 10 Shopify payment gateway issues for SMBs is the first step. 

Acting on that understanding — whether by tightening your chargeback prevention, building better documentation habits, or switching to a platform designed with your business size in mind — is what separates merchants who struggle with payments from those who don't.

Prosperna exists for the second group. If you're ready to build your online store on a platform where payments actually work the way you need them to, it's worth taking a look.

Prosperna, Your Partner to eCommerce Success

Prosperna is an all-in-one AI-powered eCommerce platform for SMBs, entrepreneurs, and content creators. Our mission is to empower 1 million businesses with simple, affordable tools powered by AI.

We’re so passionate about helping small businesses succeed that we offer a FREE account forever.

👉 Create your FREE-forever Prosperna account.